VAR got it wrong Former Premier League referee Mark Halsey blasts technology after Champions League shambles

VAR got it wrong Former Premier League referee Mark Halsey blasts technology after Champions League shambles
Former Premier League referee Mark Halsey has slammed VAR after the new technology took centre-stage again in more Champions League controversy.Both Manchester City and Atletico Madrid fell victim to decisions made by the Video Assistant Referee on Wednesday night, and Halsey believes one of them was the wrong call.City were forced to fight for their 3-2 first leg win at Schalke, after the game swung in the home sides favour with two penalty decisions via VAR.Having led through Sergio Agueros goal, Schalke levelled through a Nabil Bentaleb spot kick after VAR overruled a corner kick call to award a penalty for an apparent handball from Nicolas Otamendi.4

Manchester City players argue with the referee during their clash with Schalke

The game was delayed by almost three minutes as players waited for the decision, after the referee walked over to pitch-side screens only to find they were not working. He had to rely solely on the decision from the VAR booth, and gave the penalty despite not watching the incident back himself.VAR was also briefly consulted for Schalkes second penalty after a foul by Fernandinho, but City rallied late on to win 3-2 thanks to late goals from Leroy Sane and Raheem Sterling.There was also controversy in the nights other game, with Atletico denied a penalty and an Alvaro Morata goal by VAR before going on to beat Juventus 2-0 in Spain.4

The referee consults the VAR screen – which was working at Atletico’s clash against Juventus

4

Alvaro Morata is yet to open his account for Atletico, having now had two goals chalked off by VAR

And ex-top flight referee Halsey, who watched Citys match, admitted it was another embarrassing evening for the new technology.UEFA have brought the use of VAR forward for this seasons last-16 stage of the Champions League but it appears to only have raised more questions, with Ajax also denied what would have been a match-winning goal against Real Madrid last week.Halsey said the handball given against City defender Otamendi should not have been given, and that VAR should have been abandoned altogether when they found the screens were faulty.I wouldnt be happy about that, he told the Alan Brazil Sports Breakfast.UEFA had a meeting in London where they emphasised that the on-field referee must make the final decision and its appropriate he visits the screen.If that screen is not working, and surely it was tested before the game started, then VAR should not be used on the night. They should forget about VAR and go with the on-field referee for the rest of the game.4

The referee for Schalke v Man City still used VAR despite not being able to review the incidents himself

Asked about the handball, he added: It has to be a deliberate movement.Lots of players use their arms for balance and you cant make a tackle sometimes without using your arms for balance. The question is was there a deliberate movement of the arm towards the ball?In my opinion, the handball shouldnt have been given. They should have just given a corner and got on with it.If video referees are taking in excess of three minutes to come to that decision, was it clear and obvious? Youd have to say no!

Listen back to Mark Halsey’s VAR verdict on the Alan Brazil Sports Breakfast above!

---

The latest Tweets from The United Stand (@UnitedStandMUFC). Manchester United's Biggest Unofficial Independent Fan Channel! Enquiries Soccerboxtv@gmail.com Get TUS Merch on link BELOW!

---

Tottenham new stadium update: Spurs agree deal to use Wembley

---

How Thierry Henry's Monaco could look at the end of January with Cesc Fabregas and Michy Batshuayi from Chelsea They've already secured Fabregas' signature but Monaco will be looking to recruit
How Thierry Henry's Monaco could look at the end of January

---

Juventus 'offer Man Utd Paulo Dybala AND Alex Sandro' for Paul Pogba transfer. Paul Pogba is also on Real Madrid's radar but Man Utd might prefer the player sway option from Juventus
Manchester United Transfer News: Juventus Seeking Paul Pogba

---

Manchester United 'given boost' in pursuit of Liverpool and Barcelona target Matthijs de Ligt Reports in Spain suggest the 19-year-old's agent, Mino Raiola, would rather he joined United over
Manchester United 'given boost' in pursuit of Liverpool and

---

Kepa Arrizabalaga: Chelsea star 'told Willy Caballero he was

---

'Manchester United CAN'T drop David de Gea', insists Ray Parlour on talkSPORT Ray Parlour insists David de Gea is one of the world's best goalkeepers and remains undroppable for Manchester United, despite his recent mistakes. The Spanish glovesman was guilty of another howler.. talkSPORT - Published on April 29, 2019
Worried about the world economy This week we find out just

---

Sam Allardyce has not forgiven Everton for dismissing him as manager and believes his successor Marco Silva could suffer the same fate.
Allardyce slams 'ludicrous' decision by Everton to sack him

---

Ex-Liverpool star slams 'rat' Luis Suarez ahead of Barcelona second leg branded a 'rat' by Liverpool legend John Aldridge on the eve of the like a rat in the Champions League semi-final
Liverpool news: John Aldridge BLASTS Barcelona star Luis

---

PAPER TALK Transfer news and football gossip: De Ligt responds to Man United links, Real Madrid chief confirms he 'wants' Hazard, Martinez set for Barcelona job?
De Ligt responds to Man United links, Real Madrid chief
fussboll.com/2019/05/28/de-ligt-responds-to-man-united-links-real-madrid-chief-confirms-he-wants-hazard-martinez-set-for-barcelona-job/
talkSPORT.com rounds up all the latest transfer news and football […] De Ligt responds to Man United links, Real Madrid chief confirms he 'wants' Hazard, Martinez set for Barcelona job? - Fussboll
Transfer news and football gossip: De Ligt responds to Man

---

Next Manchester United manager will NOT be announced before end of the season, Ed Woodward tells talkSPORT Share or comment on this article: Man United chief Ed Woodward has been 'inundated with
Manchester United will NOT confirm new boss before the end of

---